Are Farmers the Last American Workers Stuck in the Paper Age

Walk into nearly any hospital, law office, or school in America, and you’ll likely see sleek digital systems quietly running the show—scheduling, tracking, billing, and reporting. Yet, take a detour into a typical family farm in rural areas of states like North Carolina, Louisiana, or even New York, and the story changes. Despite leading the charge in feeding the nation, many American farmers are still buried under a mountain of paper—handwritten logs, physical timecards, carbon-copy invoices, and spreadsheet printouts.

It raises the question: Are farmers the last American workers stuck in the paper age?

A Sector Slow to Digitize

U.S. agriculture, particularly small farms and family farms, have historically been slow to adopt digital systems. While mechanization revolutionized crop production in the 20th century, the 21st-century digital revolution has yet to fully reach the furrows of America’s fields.

According to the USDA’s Economic Research Service, the average age of the American farm operator is 58. That demographic skews higher than nearly any other industry, and older operators are less likely to transition to digital platforms. Many still rely on pen and paper for payroll, pesticide applications, yield tracking, and even compliance documentation for the U.S. Department of Labor and other gov agencies.

The Paper Burden

Farm labor, particularly involving migrant workers and the H-2A program, comes with a maze of compliance paperwork. Growers must log hours worked, verify employment eligibility, and comply with child labor laws and minimum wage regulations. Much of this still happens on paper, increasing the risk of errors, lost documents, and compliance violations.

Consider Florida citrus growers who employ hundreds of seasonal and migrant workers. Each worker’s time must be tracked, and detailed logs must be kept for labor audits. Yet in many operations, this is still done using manual timesheets clipped to dusty bulletin boards. It's time-consuming, inefficient, and risky.

Why It Matters

This paper-heavy approach isn’t just inconvenient—it’s holding the agriculture sector back. Manual processes cost time, reduce accuracy, and make it harder for farmers to respond quickly to changes in the labor market or crop demands.

Moreover, the agriculture sector’s dependence on paper can have serious consequences. In 2023, the U.S. Department of Labor cited multiple farms in Louisiana and North Carolina for violations related to migrant worker documentation. These weren’t malicious oversights—they were often the result of poor, outdated record keeping.

The Digital Divide in Rural America

Digital adoption in agriculture is about more than software—it’s about access. Many family farms in rural areas still struggle with broadband internet access. According to the USDA, nearly 22% of Americans in rural areas lack reliable broadband. That’s a major barrier to implementing digital platforms for bookkeeping, HR, crop analytics, and communication.

Even in 2025, some parts of the American farm economy feel like stepping back into 1995.

Cultural and Economic Barriers

There’s also a cultural component. Farmers, especially older generations, often trust systems they’ve used for decades. Transitioning to a digital time tracking or bookkeeping system feels risky. What if it crashes? What if the data disappears? And frankly, with razor-thin margins and fluctuating crop prices, investing in a new system can feel like a gamble.

This hesitancy is especially strong on small farms where family members do most of the work and where hiring a full-time office manager isn’t feasible.

The Bright Spots

Yet, there are signs of progress. Cooperatives and land-grant universities are stepping in to provide training on digital tools. New apps are emerging that cater specifically to the unique needs of agricultural workers and farm operators.

In New York, a regional cooperative developed a mobile-friendly app to help dairy farms digitally log milk production and labor hours. In Florida, some citrus growers are piloting RFID badges to track worker hours digitally. And in North Carolina, one high school is partnering with local farms to train the next generation of farmers in digital record keeping.

Policy's Role

The Farm Bill plays a crucial role here. While it often focuses on subsidies and insurance programs, it also includes funding for rural broadband expansion, digital training, and support for small farms transitioning to new technologies.

Government parties have acknowledged the need to modernize agriculture’s backend operations. Some proposals even include grants to help farmers adopt digital compliance systems—potentially reducing paperwork tied to the H-2A program, pesticide tracking, and the U.S. Department of Agriculture audits.

Economic Consequences of Staying Analog

Failing to digitize has consequences beyond compliance. It affects the entire supply chain. Buyers and distributors increasingly demand digital traceability. If an American farm can’t provide digital proof of where, when, and how a crop was grown, they may lose access to premium markets.

Additionally, staying on paper makes it harder to adapt to labor force changes. With fewer young people entering agricultural jobs and an aging population of farm operators, the industry needs tools that make running a farm more efficient, not more cumbersome.

Labor Market Realities

According to recent data, only 2% of the U.S. workforce is involved in agriculture. Of those, a growing number are migrant workers and temporary laborers. Without efficient digital systems, managing this transient workforce becomes a logistical nightmare. Time tracking, housing assignments, healthcare access, and wage reporting—all of it is exponentially harder on paper.

Meanwhile, American farmers are dealing with more oversight. From child labor audits to pesticide usage logs, it’s more important than ever to have quick, searchable records.

What Needs to Change

So, what’s the path forward?

1. Expand broadband access – Without internet, digital adoption is dead in the water. This must be the top priority for rural development.
2. Offer incentives for tech adoption – The government can help defray the cost of new systems and training, particularly for small and mid-sized farms.
3. Develop ag-specific software – Many existing business tools don’t fit the seasonal, outdoor, and crew-based realities of farm labor. More ag-specific solutions are needed.
4. Train the next generation – High schools, community colleges, and cooperative extensions must prioritize digital literacy for the future of U.S. agriculture.
5. Support cooperatives – These organizations can act as digital bridges, helping their members pool resources and adopt systems together.

The Human Side

Talk to a 60-year-old soybean farmer in the Midwest, and he’ll likely tell you the same thing: "I’d rather be in the field than in front of a computer." That’s fair. But with more American farm families under financial stress, the ability to streamline operations and stay compliant is essential for survival. FarmRaise, is a farm accounting software that helps farmers access funding, manage records, keeps track of inventory, creates invoices, offers payroll and showcases financial tools that are tailored specifically to agricultural operations. It simplifies paperwork by streamlining USDA applications, cost-share programs, and conservation incentives into a centralized, farmer-friendly dashboard. Designed for both small and large farms, FarmRaise empowers growers to make data-driven decisions without getting buried in red tape.

Farmers aren’t lacking in trying to increase technology into their practices. They’ve adopted GPS tractors, automated irrigation, and precision spraying. But when it comes to the back office, many are still stuck in the paper age.

It’s not laziness—it’s lack of support, access, and tailored solutions.

Final Thoughts

If America wants a resilient, efficient agriculture sector, it must invest in digitization—not just in machines that plant soybeans, but in the systems that run payroll, report to the U.S. Department of Labor, and manage the day-to-day complexity of modern farming.

The average American farm is both a workplace and a home. Its labor force includes migrants, full-time staff, and family members. Its challenges span weather, politics, and economics. And in this high-stakes environment, the analog tools of the past simply can’t keep up.

It’s time to bring American farmers into the digital era—not just to help them survive, but to ensure they thrive in a modern, connected, and ever-demanding agricultural economy.

Because the future of farming shouldn’t be written in ink—it should be stored in the cloud.

Ready to get started with FarmRaise today? Use code 8MELC9 for 20% off or click here to get started.

‍